Another week has been completed in my 3rd and 4th courses of my master's. Summer has set in. It's now just as important to have the air conditioner going to de-humidify as it is to cool. Laundry is about 40 minutes to wash and three or four days to dry. I went to the farther away grocery store today to get some things that are cheaper than the Ass Mart. It's only a 40-minute walk, but in the heat and humidity (28 degree Celsius and raining) it was a full on sweat. Here is what I have chosen to be the best thing I wrote this week. I'm not sure I'll get the best grade on it because it's basically slagging most of the crap I read in the course this week. But it deserved to be slagged. Read and see...
Alfie and Jack
“The whole field of classroom management amounts to techniques for
manipulating students’ behavior. This takes for granted that the fault lies
with the children”
If one thinks of the classroom as a totalitarian state in which
the teacher’s classroom management responsibilities include making the students
love their servitude, you will understand why it is “an especially fertile
terrain for any technique or plan which promises effective ways to make the
classroom a peaceful and productive place”
One of the best examples of classroom management theory that is
practicing totalitarian coercion and not considering the student’s point of
view is the hypothetical example of “Jack” given in the writings of Spencer
Kagan creator of “win-win discipline” and the list of “7 positions” from which
a student’s misbehavior originates
Admittedly, the revolutionary change the Kohn theories support
would not be welcomed by everyone. There are reasons why some countries have
kids in schools for long hours and unsurprisingly, in countries where parents
tend to work longer hours, children spend longer hours in the classroom. Also
unsurprisingly, a lot of the same countries have education systems that are
highly influenced by very strong industrial lobbies. Most of these countries have expensive
daycare as well. As much as a teacher hates to hear it, part of the job is
taking care of kids while parents (more and more often both parents) are
working. Revolutionary thinking like addressing the real reasons there are so
many behavioral problems in schools is possible, take Finland for example
For industry and people with strong political commitments or who
are fearful of the costs of educational revolution, the Kagan system is a
positive alternative to doing what Finland did and what Kohn would like to see
in America, and that is understandable. This author would love to see such an
educational revolution in Canada and is a huge Alfie Kohn fan. There is hope
that industry’s changing needs due to automation could finally open other
countries to more Finnish-like education systems, but that is only likely to
happen when industry is good and ready. Until then, teachers will have to plate
spin the many classroom management theories instead of addressing the actual
sources of the behavior problems. “Changing
your behavior and strategies is often the most efficient and effective means of
improving all types of classroom behaviors… The building block of emotions and
behavior likely contains the largest and most diverse set of problems
encountered in the classroom. By first understanding these problems and seeing
the world through the eyes of your students, and, by then developing and using
a set of intervention strategies on a regular basis, problems of emotions and
behavior can be effectively managed and changed in the classroom”
Carney, M. (2015). Internet-addicted South Korean
children sent to digital detox boot camp. ABC News Australia.
Retrieved June 18, 2022, from https://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-09-13/south-korean-children-seek-help-at-digital-detox-boot-camp/6769766
Kagan, S. (2002). What is win-win discipline? Kagan
Online Magazine. Retrieved June 27, 2022, from https://www.kaganonline.com/free_articles/dr_spencer_kagan/ASK15.php
Kohn, A. (2006). The homework myth: Why our kids
get too much of a bad thing. Cambridge, MA: Da Capo Life Long. https://www.alfiekohn.org/homework-improve-learning/
Loveless, B. (2022). 27 surprising Finnish education
system facts and statistics. Education Corner. Retrieved June 27,
2022, from https://www.educationcorner.com/finland-education-system/
Mather, N., & Goldstein, S. (n.d.). Behavior
modification in the classroom. LD online. https://www.ldonline.org/ld-topics/classroom-management/behavior-modification-classroom