Here's a video well worth watching:
At this point in my life I have still not completely ruled out working in China again. Luckily for me I think China and its ESL racket have effectively ruled me out. I think it is mostly because of my age but for all I know it could have something to do with their social credit system. There is a GLARING weakness to this system and I have fallen victim to it in every country I've lived with the possible exception of Japan. I didn't live there long enough.Take a look at my recent posts and experiences right here in Canada. Also, while watching the above video I thought of some of my experiences in Korea. China may believe they are way ahead of other countries in their social credit technology but in my opinion they are simply the only country that is comfortable sharing it with its citizens. And when you look at the stunning nonchalance with which Lulu, the videographer's wife, took the news that facial reading technology had been widely set up with HER face, without her permission, you see how The Party has efficiently socialized citizens of China. In common non-Party reasoning a person's face belongs to that person. No company has the right to use it in thousands of ID systems around the country despite how convenient it may be to get water from a vending machine by only scanning your face. This is not Shi Jin Ping thought. It's the sort of thinking that can cost you social credit points.
But is China the only country that does this? I doubt it. Let's go to the beginning. When the uni prof is interviewed he states that China wondered how there could be more fraud in China than the west and found that it was because of credit rating. If you have read my two posts about credit rating and how thoroughly corrupted it is in Canada you will know the giant flaw in the social credit system, but let's hold off on that for the moment. Credit ratings are generally accepted and a more and more accessible and widely used indicator of honesty in Canada. They used to be accessible only to certain organizations like banks or institutes where people can borrow money, but now any Joe Blow who wants to rent you a room in his basement can pull out his phone and get a sort of Canadian social credit score, can't he? You ask the average Canadian and they will give you a similar reaction to Lulu and say that this keeps people more honest in Canada. Does it? Does the social credit system in China keep people more honest like they assure you it does in the video?
NO.
The glaring flaw was illustrated quite clearly in my recent attempt to clear my credit rating here in Canada. You can read about it in the posts Give Me a Little Credit Will You? and Give Me a Little Credit Won't You? A major company like Telus, one of the Triumvirate of Evil, along with Bell and Roger's that hold an illegal but allowed monopoly on telecom in Canada can easily exploit and manipulate credit ratings and make life difficult for anyone they want. They are not questioned by credit rating companies and credit rating companies are not questioned by anyone either. What I'm saying is there is no regulation and despite the history of disaster in Canada when things become de-regulated, this is the direction we're told our people want to go. And... again... this will lead to disaster.
But back to China. Rather than making their country more honest and/or reducing fraud, all they will find the social credit system will do is move it upward in class and without much exposure to Shi Jin Ping thought, it would be a very difficult task to convince me that this is not and intentional part of the whole social credit system of China.
Go to the part in the video when the uni prof does a credit check on Lulu's phone and tells her that she could stay in certain hotels without paying certain fees AND she could have an easier time with immigration in countries like Argentina, Latvia, and... CANADA! This instantly made me think of all the trouble I had at immigration offices in both China and Korea when I stayed there. It was as if the opposite of what Lulu had done to get an easier time at immigration offices had been done by me. But what could that have been? Telecom again. I bought 6 months of phone/internet from Hanaro Telecom when I worked in Mokpo at Mokpo National University. The lady at the Hanaro office said other teachers had done it for 6 months, she promised that there would be no locking me into longer term contracts like a year or two years, that it was month-to-month and I could cancel when I left. She lied. It was her JOB to lie. And when I tried to protest, she looked me right in the eye and denied saying any of this. Then she had a nice meal and slept soundly I presume.
Even though Hanaro is now out of business; even though they were found to be defrauding customers; even though there was a well-publicized class action lawsuit against them for sharing sensitive information of 6-7 million customers; even though they were also sued for price fixing; they just merged with SK Telecom making the Korean telecom monopoly more effective. I probably could have gotten in on that class action lawsuit and participated in suing Hanaro ffs! But even though the company is clearly and thoroughly corrupt, I try to get internet from any of the Triumvirate of Evil in Korea (KT, LG, or SKT) and they refuse because I didn't pay Hanaro for 6 months of service in Mokpo when I was no longer living in Mokpo 18 years ago or whatever it was. I am pretty sure my consistent trouble with immigrations were the result of being flagged too and the Hanaro incident no doubt factored into that. Am I saying Korea has a social credit system of its own? Yes, that's exactly what I'm saying. If you had been in Korea right when the pandemic started you should probably think so too. But even in Korea people can see things happen that should cause them grave concern over rights and freedom violations but they shrug them off like Lulu.
There was a guy found to have Covid 19 in Korea. A gay guy. A foreign guy if I remember correctly. Within hours EVERY person in Korea who had been in the same establishments as him was contacted by phone and given a message to immediately get tested. They HAVE a social credit system in Korea. They just don't tell the citizens about it so that they'll THINK they have more rights and freedoms than the citizens of China.
Then there was China. They have 4 big banks but it doesn't seem like it. ICBC, the world's largest bank, is the one everyone uses. The others are mostly industrial. Again a monopoly so again they get away with whatever the frig they want. I've blogged about it before - they have the only cash machines in the world that are set up to make you leave your card in them. You get your cash before you get your card back. You actually have to press more buttons to get your card back after you have the cash. If you don't, the machine eats your card, your bank account gets FROZEN, and you can't get your card back unless you go to the bank and basically start a new account all over again. This too is by design. It gives the bank an excuse to find out what you're up to and for foreigners it's more important in case you're transferring too much money out of China or other suspicious activity. Most people have this happen to them at least once if they stay in China awhile. It happened to me five times I think? For this I was probably flagged and paid extra attention to.
What about Canada? We definitely THINK we have more rights and freedoms than the folks in China, but do we? I STILL get ads for the X Files on my phone because when I was visiting my brother Jeff in March, half a year ago, we watched a few episodes of it. Don't kid yourself, nothing you do in Canada is private either. Don't forget what I found out and blogged about only a few months ago: I was flagged for not using my social insurance number. FLAGGED. I was told as much by the worker at the office where they flagged me. What happens when you're flagged? Government websites don't work. They don't tell you, "Hey this is your government. Why aren't you using your SIN?" They just make your life a lot more frustrating. I'm not convinced my troubles with immigration overseas didn't also have something to do with that as well. We are monitored just like the Chinese. And if we're playing the game, we get rewards. If we're not borrowing money, building credit, paying taxes, making ourselves easier to monitor, we get punished.
Big companies will exploit and manipulate people, innocent and honest people, by using the social credit system of China to punish people for not giving their companies enough money. They are already doing it. It is literally impossible to get a bank account without a phone in China. So there are two companies (most likely ICBC and China Mobile (about a billion customers)) who you have almost no choice but to use. Woe unto you and your social credit score if you miss a cell payment or get an insufficient funds charge. It is still possible to live a life without a car loan, house loan, credit card, line of credit, or things like these but you have to be weird to do it. Wonkda in Korea. Basically antisocial in North America. But what's to stop the credit and loan companies who are absolutely notorious for cheating customers... from cheating their customers MORE? Once they have to protection of unimpeachable honesty gifted by the social credit system, why wouldn't they just create bullshit charges for people who they feel aren't being good enough customers? The folks will pay or their social credit scores will be affected. The companies cannot be questioned because they are controlled by unregulated bodies - in China the CPP, everywhere else unregulated private entities - so they will either get your money or kill your score. Pretty sweet for THEM and pretty sucky for US the little guys.
The video about China is tagged as a "dystopian reality." It's just a reality. Life is already dehumanized, fearful, and wretched for everyone but the super rich. Dystopian. It just becomes more so every day. How long before people hack this system and if I'm one of them I can just punch a few numbers into my phone and affect someone else's credit score? Someone I like or someone I want to cause problems for. Is it already possible? I think it is. And that is scary. If someone doesn't like you because you slept with his wife, or you parked in his favourite spot, or you are a foreigner, all he needs is fingerprint or face and he can make it look like you crossed the street on a red light. I'm sure it can be a helluva lot worse than that too! I don't think there's much futuristic about this, I think it's widespread already, it's just not hidden in China. And all the talk about making life more harmonious and honest is pure nonsense. This is nothing more than another way to enrich the already rich and impoverish the already poor. And a communist country is bragging about it! Shame on China... and the rest of the world.








